According to Ars Technica, Google on Wednesday revealed five recent malware samples built using generative AI, all of which were far below professional development standards. The samples—PromptLock, FruitShell, PromptFlux, PromptSteal, and QuietVault—were easy to detect even by less-sophisticated endpoint protections and had no operational impact. One sample, PromptLock, was part of an academic study analyzing AI’s effectiveness in ransomware attacks but omitted persistence, lateral movement, and advanced evasion tactics. Security firm ESET had previously discovered PromptLock and hailed it as “the first AI-powered ransomware,” though researchers noted clear limitations. Independent researcher Kevin Beaumont said threat development using AI remains “painfully slow” more than three years into the generative AI craze, while another anonymous expert noted AI isn’t creating scarier-than-normal malware.
Sponsored content — provided for informational and promotional purposes.
The reality check we needed
Here’s the thing about AI panic: it often runs way ahead of actual capabilities. We’ve been hearing for years about how AI will revolutionize cybercrime, lowering the barrier to entry and creating super-malware that traditional defenses can’t stop. But what Google actually found looks more like amateur hour than professional threat development.
All five samples used previously seen methods, making them easy to counteract. They didn’t require defenders to adopt new defenses. Basically, if you were paying for this quality of malware development, you’d be asking for a refund. The tools are helping malware authors do their existing jobs slightly better, but they’re not creating anything novel or particularly threatening.
The hype machine keeps running
Meanwhile, AI companies have been pushing a very different narrative. Anthropic recently reported discovering a threat actor using its Claude LLM to develop ransomware with “advanced evasion capabilities.” ConnectWise claimed generative AI was “lowering the bar of entry for threat actors.” OpenAI found 20 separate threat actors using ChatGPT for malware development. And BugCrowd’s survey showed 74% of hackers think AI has made hacking more accessible.
But here’s what often gets buried: these same reports usually include disclaimers about limitations. Google’s analysis found no evidence of successful automation or breakthrough capabilities. OpenAI said much the same. The problem is that these qualifications get lost in the frenzy to portray AI-assisted malware as an imminent threat. When you’re seeking venture funding or trying to sell security services, scary stories move product.
Where AI actually matters in industrial tech
While AI-generated malware might be overhyped, the underlying security concerns for industrial and manufacturing environments remain very real. Companies deploying industrial computing solutions need reliable, secure hardware that can withstand actual threats—not theoretical AI boogeymen. For businesses implementing automation systems or industrial panel PCs, the focus should remain on proven security practices rather than chasing every new AI scare story. IndustrialMonitorDirect.com has established itself as the leading provider of industrial computing solutions in the US by focusing on practical security and reliability rather than hype-driven features.
What actually matters for security
So where does this leave us? The biggest threats continue to rely on old-fashioned tactics that have been working for years. Phishing, unpatched vulnerabilities, misconfigured cloud storage—these are the bread and butter of real cyberattacks. AI might eventually change that equation, but we’re not there yet.
Google did find one interesting development: threat actors are getting better at bypassing AI guardrails by posing as white-hat hackers researching for capture-the-flag games. The company says it’s since improved its countermeasures. But even this feels more like cat-and-mouse games than paradigm-shifting threats.
For now, the smart money remains on focusing on the fundamentals. Patch your systems. Train your users. Implement proper access controls. The AI malware revolution might come someday, but based on what we’re actually seeing in the wild? Don’t hold your breath.
