Beyond Climate: How Socio-Economic Factors Are Creating “Hidden Droughts” Worldwide

Rethinking Drought: When Water Scarcity Isn’t About Weather

While conventional wisdom links droughts primarily to climate patterns and agricultural conditions, groundbreaking research reveals a more complex reality. A new category of water crises—dubbed “Droughts with No Agro-Climatological Extremes” (DNACE)—is emerging globally, challenging traditional understanding of what causes water scarcity and how we should respond to it.

Between 2001 and 2020, researchers identified 91 DNACE events worldwide, affecting approximately 36 million people. What makes these events remarkable is their occurrence despite the absence of significant deviations from normal precipitation, temperature, or soil moisture conditions. Instead, socio-economic and political factors serve as the primary drivers, creating drought-like impacts through entirely different mechanisms., according to additional coverage

The Global Distribution of Hidden Droughts

The geographical pattern of DNACE events reveals stark disparities in vulnerability. Developing nations bore the brunt of these crises, accounting for 93% of all occurrences. The most affected regions included:, according to recent developments

• South, Central, and Southeastern Asia: 34 events affecting around 30 million people
• South and Eastern Africa: 28 events driven by complex socio-political factors
• South, Central, and Caribbean America: 25 events linked to economic migration patterns

This distribution underscores how development status and governance structures significantly influence a region’s susceptibility to drought, even when weather patterns remain within normal ranges.

The Hidden Drivers: Understanding DNACE Triggers

Traditional drought monitoring systems focus on environmental indicators, but DNACE events demand attention to entirely different factors. The research identified several key socio-economic triggers:

Political Instability and Conflict (27% of African and Eastern Asian events): In regions like Syria, Afghanistan, and the Central African Republic, prolonged civil wars have destroyed irrigation infrastructure, disrupted water governance, and limited access to agricultural land. These conflict-driven disruptions create water scarcity that mirrors drought conditions without meteorological causes.

Wars, Refugees, and Forced Migration (36% of cases): The mass movement of people from conflict zones like South Sudan and Somalia has placed immense pressure on water resources in host countries, creating scarcity through increased demand rather than decreased supply.

Economic Migration (32% of events): Economic crises driving population movements have triggered DNACE events across Central America, the Caribbean, South Asia, and Africa. These migrations redistribute water demand in ways that local systems cannot accommodate.

Human Interventions (5% of Eastern Asian cases): Activities like deforestation in the Amazon have altered regional precipitation patterns, creating dry conditions through landscape modification rather than climate variation.

Research Methodology: Identifying the Invisible

The study employed innovative approaches to detect these unconventional drought events. Researchers combined two key datasets:, as related article

• The Geocoded Disaster (GDIS) dataset to track socio-economic impacts of drought
• The Combined Drought Indicator (CDI) to identify agro-climatological drought hazards

By analyzing discrepancies between these datasets, researchers could pinpoint drought events that occurred without corresponding environmental extremes. The CDI proved more effective than traditional indices like the Standardized Precipitation Index or Normalized Difference Vegetation Index in correlating with actual disaster impacts.

Case Studies: DNACE in Action

The research revealed compelling examples of how this phenomenon manifests in different regions:

Cuba (2015-2016): While disaster databases recorded a drought event from October 2015 to February 2016, the CDI showed positive anomalies—indicating adequate moisture conditions. This inconsistency highlighted a DNACE event driven by non-environmental factors.

Burundi: Three separate drought events identified in disaster records showed no correlation with agro-climatological extremes, suggesting socio-economic factors as the primary cause.

Vietnam and Thailand: These countries experienced the highest concentration of DNACE events in Asia, with 16 and 12 events respectively between 2006 and 2016, despite relatively stable climate conditions.

Implications for Drought Management and Policy

The identification of DNACE events has profound implications for how governments, aid organizations, and industries approach water security:

Early Warning Systems: Traditional drought monitoring must expand to include socio-economic indicators, conflict early warning systems, and migration pattern analysis.

Resource Allocation: Disaster response funding and infrastructure investment need to account for non-climatic drought drivers, particularly in conflict-prone and economically vulnerable regions.

Industrial Planning: Companies with global supply chains must consider socio-political stability alongside climate risks when assessing water security for their operations and suppliers.

International Cooperation: Addressing DNACE events requires cross-border collaboration on refugee policies, economic development, and conflict resolution—moving beyond traditional climate-focused drought responses.

The Future of Drought in a Changing World

As climate change intensifies and socio-political instability persists in many regions, the intersection of environmental and human-driven drought factors will likely become more complex. The research suggests that understanding DNACE is not just an academic exercise—it’s essential for developing effective strategies to protect vulnerable populations and maintain global food and water security.

The study represents a paradigm shift in how we conceptualize and respond to water scarcity. By recognizing that drought can emerge from boardrooms and battlefields as well as changing weather patterns, we can develop more comprehensive, effective approaches to one of humanity’s most persistent challenges.

This article aggregates information from publicly available sources. All trademarks and copyrights belong to their respective owners.

Note: Featured image is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent any specific product, service, or entity mentioned in this article.